OSKALOOSA —
The prosecution and defense have given their closing arguments in the first-degree murder trial of Brad Arterburn in Mahaska County District Court.
Arterburn, 27, of Oskaloosa, has been charged with the first-degree murder of his mother’s boyfriend, Robert Henry “Hank” Horovitz, 58, of Davenport, on June 19, 2011. Arterburn entered a plea of not guilty in Mahaska County Court July 12, 2011.
Prosecutor Denise Timmins argued that Arterburn committed a “heinous act” and took the life of Horovitz.
“Your duty is to seek the truth,” she said.
She argued Arterburn acted with deliberation and malice.
“The defendant has the burden to prove insanity,” she said.
Defense attorney Ken Duker argued there was no financial motive for Arterburn’s actions. Also, he argued the state’s professional witness diagnosed Arterburn in his clinical judgment — subjectively and not objectively. He argued that the defense’s witnesses utilized objective as well as subjective tests in diagnosing Arterburn. He also argued that Arterburn acted in self-defense and was not rational when he thought he was defending himself against his abuser Dave Myers.
Duker’s conclusion was that Arterburn was not guilty by reason of insanity.
In follow-up statements, Timmins argued that if Arterburn truly believed he had killed his abuser — Myers — and not Horovitz, wouldn’t he have told everyone about it? Instead, when police arrived on scene, he was calmly smoking a cigarette on the deck behind the house.
Testimony from two mental health professionals Tuesday morning set the stage for closing arguments.
Psychiatrist Dr. James Dennert testified for the prosecution and clinical psychologist Dr. Craig Rypma testified for the defense.
Dennert examined Arterburn in September and conducted interviews with him and reviewed records and testimony concerning the case.
Dennert determined that Arterburn’s state of mind was such that he understood the nature and consequences of his actions, he understood the difference between right and wrong and acted with intent.
Dennert also determined that Arterburn was not in a disassociative state at the time of his interview with DCI agent Adam De Camp.
Dennert said that when Arterburn said he was having flashbacks during court testimony Monday, he was not having one in psychiatric terms. Dennert said he did not indicate that he was reliving actual events while in the courtroom. He was likely having vivid memories of abuse.
Also, Dennert said that Arterburn did not have a psychotic episode on June 19, 2011.
Dennert said he diagnosed Arterburn with a depressive disorder.
Rypma said he examined Arterburn and administered the MMPI test, an objective test of a person’s state of mind. He said the results of the test showed that Arterburn had elevated results to indicate psychotic thinking and a mood disturbance.
Rypma also said Arterburn has an IQ of 91, which is on the low end of the normal category.
Rypma observed Arterburn on the witness stand Monday and said that showed a person with a 91 IQ interacting with people whose IQs were 120. It also showed that Arterburn is a person who is open to suggestion and easily led to desired answers.
Rypma said Arterburn suffered from “black feelings” throughout his teen years. Rypma said those are similar to alcohol-induced blackouts people have.
Rypma said a review of the DCI interview indicated that Arterburn was confused during questioning.
Rypma said he determined that Arterburn could not understand the nature and quality of his actions on June 19, 2011. He also couldn’t distinguish between right and wrong.
CNHI/Southeast Iowa
Closing arguments heard in Arterburn trial
- CNHI/Southeast Iowa
-
-
Okla. officials vow not to quit looking until everyone is found
The tornado that killed 24 people and injured at least 100 others in the Moore and Oklahoma City area cut a 17-mile-long path that started in Newcastle and ended at Lake Stanley Draper. Nine of the dead are children.
-
Photos: Aftermath of massive tornado in Moore
Storm victims were pulled from the rubble and residents began surveying the damage late Monday and early Tuesday in the Oklahoma City suburb of Moore, where a powerful tornado destroyed entire neighborhoods and left dozens dead.
-
Where to get the best deal on beer, haircuts, movies
Looking for a good deal on a six-pack of beer? Try Charlotte. A haircut that won't burn a hole in your wallet? Harlingen, Texas, is your best bet. A trip to the movies? Hilo, Hawaii, is supposed to be nice this time of year.
-
VIDEO: Tornado survivor's missing dog found during TV interview
Barbara Garcia was being interviewed by CBS News about how she survived the destruction of her home to Monday's massive tornado in Moore, when the dog she feared dead was suddenly discovered alive in the rubble of her home.
-
Barber shows no signs of cutting career short
OTTUMWA -- Darrell Smith's hands are steady and sure as he picks up his clippers and straight razor to begin his first haircut and shave of the day. Smith, 88, has cut hair for 62 years and has owned Smitty's Barber Shop on Albia Road for the past 58
-
Okla. front pages capture tornado aftermath
View how several Oklahoma newspapers covered Monday's massive tornado in Moore. Please note that officials revised the death toll downward early Tuesday morning after some papers were printed, but it is expected to climb again as recovery efforts continue.
-
Corn planting soars on break in the weather
The percentage of corn planted in Iowa grew by more than 50 percentage points last week with what experts called the first really good week of weather for farmers.
-
VIDEO: Pres. Obama's remarks on the Okla. tornado
President Obama speaks on Monday's deadly Okla. tornado.
-
LIVE BLOG: Massive tornado hits south of OKC
A massive tornado touched down Monday afternoon in Moore, Okla., just south of Oklahoma City. Follow live coverage of the aftermath of the storm.
-
VIDEO: Tumblr sold to Yahoo! for $1.1 billion
Yahoo! has purchased Tumblr for $1.1 billion, hoping to compete more effectively with sites like Google and Facebook.
-
What you need to know about preparing for tornadoes
Tornado survivors and seasoned observers suggest people do two simple things to prepare for tornadoes: Know where to take shelter, and move quickly when the time comes.
-
VIDEO: How technology helps predict tornadoes
At the National Storm Prediction Center in Oklahoma, the team charged with predicting tornadoes relies on ever-changing technology to determine when and where storms may strike.
-
SLIDESHOW: Tornado passes through Oklahoma
A fast-moving storm brought rain, hail and tornadoes to Oklahoma late Sunday afternoon and evening.
-
Reviving downtown's upper stories
Building by building, the upper stories of downtown Ottumwa are coming back to life after some have sat empty for half a century.
-
Alleged counterfeiter arrested
The Knoxville Police Department reports having a suspect in custody who may be responsible for the counterfeit $100 circulating in town.
- More CNHI/Southeast Iowa Headlines
-
